It’s been a wild three years, hasn’t it?

Few were surprised when Austin FC – an expansion team with a roster constructed during a global pandemic – struggled in its first season. Few weren’t surprised when Austin FC defied the (laminated) predictions of MLS experts everywhere by finishing second in the Western Conference and reaching the conference final in their second season.

Now disappointment abounds in year three, as the Verde and Black are limping to a finish below the generous expanded playoff line. Austin FC fans must be flooding the phone lines of injury attorneys throughout town from the whiplash they’ve experienced in the team’s short history.

The prevailing mood of the moment is frustration. If anything, success in year two has made Austin FC’s third-year blunders that much more irritating for a fan base that remains one of the league’s most passionate.

That passion has curdled into vocal dissent over the direction of the team. Change is demanded, and change did arrive in June in the form of Rodolfo Borrell, Austin FC’s new sporting director. To call Borrell’s resume impressive would be an understatement.

Success in academy roles at Barcelona and Liverpool earned Borrell a prestigious position as Manchester City’s global scouting director in 2014. In 2016, Borrell was appointed first-team assistant coach to Pep Guardiola, the soccer world’s cardigan-wearing Godzilla. Guardiola arrives at a team and the team subsequently destroys anything and everything in its path. Manchester United, Chelsea, Arsenal – they are merely bits of discarded rubble left behind in the wake of Manchester City’s dominance under Guardiola.

During Borrell’s time as Guardiola’s assistant, Manchester City lifted the English Premier League title five times, won roughly 100 domestic cup competitions, and last season, finally won their first UEFA Champions League title.

Borrell has credentials. Take his word for it: “I come from some of the best clubs in the world,” he said during a press conference at St. David’s Performance Center last Tuesday. Borrell was ensuring those in attendance at the press conference – and the many Austin FC fans following along on social media – were aware he knows what he’s talking about when he says embattled Austin FC head coach Josh Wolff is “a very good coach” and “the right fit for us looking forward.”

And there’s the uncomfortable juxtaposition for Austin FC fans: their team has a sporting director who has worked with some of the brightest and best minds in the game (Borrell looks like he mutters more kernels of soccer wisdom in one night’s sleep than most people say in a lifetime), but that same sporting director is backing a coach with a 35.1% winning percentage.

Any enthusiasm over Borrell’s appointment – any excitement that fans can generate for what the future might hold for this team – must sit awkwardly alongside the reality that Austin FC are retaining the perceived figurehead of their futility. It would be unfair to assign Wolff blame for all of Austin FC’s struggles (though many have tried), but, as head coach, he unsurprisingly receives more vitriol directed his way than most on Austin FC’s payroll.

But could Borrell be right about Wolff? His background certainly suggests he should know a good coach when he sees one, and Wolff overseeing a second-year team’s trip to a conference final shouldn’t be scoffed at (even if the team’s over-performance of their expected goals numbers in 2022 shouldn’t be forgotten, either).

In his press conference, Borrell shared an anecdote about showing up to St. David’s Performance Center around nine in the morning after a sleep-deprived night following Austin FC’s heartbreaking late capitulation to the Los Angeles Galaxy. The weather-delayed 3-3 draw ended well after one in the morning and all but consigned Austin FC to a postseason-less 2023. “Although it was a day off for the team and everybody, Josh was already at the office,” Borrell said.

Borrell’s tale of Wolff’s dedication gave a nice insight into the coach’s noble efforts to try and un-sink an already sunk ship, but it will take more than an admirable work ethic to improve Austin FC’s fortunes in 2024. A discouraging lack of roster flexibility is one glaring impediment to Austin FC enjoying success next season.

Asked last Tuesday about the possibility of “buying down” underwhelming Designated Player Emiliano Rigoni’s contract – and thus opening up an available Designated Player spot – with Targeted Allocation Money (TAM), Borrell replied: “We are already using all the Targeted Allocation Money.” He added: “Right now, we are tied up with many things.”

Per Transfermarkt, Austin FC have used 26 players during the 2023 MLS season and those players have an average age of 28-years-old. Only Sporting Kansas City and Nashville SC have used players with an older average age. It’s impossible to say to what degree age impacted the Verde and Black’s underwhelming 2023 campaign, but it’s not exactly shocking that a greying squad would struggle to remain fit and at peak performance across four competitions.

Austin FC should aim to get younger, but a comprehensive overhaul of the roster ahead of the 2024 season seems unlikely considering the team’s financial constraints. In addition to having the same underperforming head coach, Austin FC will likely have many of the same underperforming players when they take the field next season. Lacking a strong memory might be the key to Austin FC fans generating excitement for the 2024 season.

Eric McCoy

See Full Bio