If you try really hard, you can maybe sort of see how the move makes sense.

On Tuesday, Austin FC shocked its fanbase by trading Diego Fagundez to the Los Angeles Galaxy for Memo Rodriguez and up to $300,000 in general allocation money (GAM). That figure could go as high as $900,000 with add-ons.

Fagundez was guaranteed to make a little over $1 million in 2023 – more than any other non-designated player on Austin FC’s roster. His recently-inked contract meant his hefty salary was to be on Austin FC’s books through at least 2025 (there was also an option for the 2026 season).

Despite his contract insinuating he should be a top-tier MLS attacker, Fagundez has struggled in 2023. Austin FC have played 23 MLS matches this season, and Fagundez has contributed just two goals and one assist in those contests.

A closer inspection of Fagundez’s 2022 season – by far the best of his career to this point – reveals his underlying performances weren’t as good as his raw goal and assist numbers would suggest. Last season, Fagundez scored six goals and assisted twelve. Eighteen goal contributions from a non-designated player would have any MLS team’s front office doing backflips in celebration.

However, looking at Fagundez’s 2022 expected goal and assist figures show his luck ran hot. Fagundez notched 3.8 expected goals and 7.9 expected assists (all numbers per fbref.com). An expected goals plus expected assists tally of nearly twelve is still good, if not quite $1 million-contract good. It’s not hard to imagine new sporting director Rodolfo Borrell valuing the financial flexibility of offloading Fagundez’s contract more than what Fagundez could have offered Austin FC on the field over the next few seasons.

And yet, do people watch sports because they like seeing shrewd business decisions? Austin FC fans are largely outraged over the Fagundez trade because Austin FC fans love Diego Fagundez, not just Diego Fagundez, contributor of 18 goals in 2022, but Diego Fagundez, the human being – a human being that embraced Austin FC fan culture to the absolute fullest. Whether it was meet-and-greets at HopSquad or charity foot-golf tournaments, Fagundez was inextricably linked to the local community.

For most of Austin FC’s two-and-a-half year existence the team has frustrated more than delighted. Austin FC’s outstanding second season is sandwiched between a woeful first season, and a third season that has thus far been defined by embarrassing exits in cup competitions. Being annoyed by your team underperforming is part of being a sports fan, though. That annoyance is tolerable because sports fandom can connect a person to something greater than anything a box score could capture.

Supporting a team can imbue a person with a feeling of identity and connect them with people they never would have otherwise met. Fagundez, whose beaming smile was as much the face of Austin FC as the club’s crest, helped nurture those feelings of identity and connection.

Plus, identity and connection aside, it’s difficult to see how this trade makes Austin FC anything but worse in 2023. Memo Rodriguez is a solid midfielder (his progressive passes received numbers really pop – fbref.com has him in the 99th percentile among MLS midfielders for the stat), but Austin FC have good depth and quality in midfield already. Meanwhile, the team’s forward line is falling apart.

Gyasi Zardes, Maxi Urruti, and Emiliano Rigoni are all currently injured, and Rodney Redes has been as effective as a traffic cone. For a team that sits in fifth place in the Western Conference – squarely in the playoff places – it’s bizarre they would choose to deplete an already depleted area of the squad.

But attempting to apply logic to Fagundez’s departure is misguided. This is a move that hurts the heart more than it hurts the brain. Even trying to make sense of the trade makes no sense at all.

Eric McCoy

See Full Bio