“From our perspective, it is a very poor reflection on what it is we’re trying to do with soccer at the highest level.”

Those were the words of Major League Soccer commissioner Don Garber at a recent U.S. Soccer board meeting when discussing the U.S. Open Cup. Garber mentioned the quality of matches and poor playing surfaces as reasons the competition fails to portray U.S. soccer in a positive light.

The U.S. Open Cup has history. In fact, it has a whole lot more history than MLS. The U.S. Open Cup was founded in 1914 (MLS was founded in 1993 and played its first season in 1996) and until COVID interrupted it in 2020, the competition had been contested for 106 consecutive years.

Roughly 100 teams feature in the tournament. Teams from MLS, the United Soccer League, and the National Independent Soccer Association all compete. Amateur teams also mix it up with the pros and semi-pros. Those amateur teams and the non-MLS professional and semi-professional teams don’t always play on Apple TV Plus quality fields (let’s forget for a second that New York City FC – a flagship MLS club – regularly plays home matches in not one, but two different baseball stadiums). Hence, Garber taking umbrage with U.S. Open Cup playing surfaces.

Watching MLS teams play soccer in minor league baseball stadiums, high school football stadiums, or whatever facility a team like Flower City play their matches in is a feature, not a bug of the U.S. Open Cup. We’re used to seeing pros play in pro stadiums. We aren’t used to seeing them play on a field an errant Emiliano Rigoni cross away from Mrs. Davidson’s trigonometry classroom.

Q2 Stadium’s pristine grass on Wednesday night likely met the lofty standards of the MLS commissioner. The starting eleven sent out by Austin FC coach Josh Wolff to face the USL’s New Mexico United was also of an MLS standard. Perhaps the 3-0 first-leg CONCACAF Champions League defeat (debacle) in the Dominican Republic against Violette AC earlier this season was on Wolff’s mind. A modest four changes were made from the eleven that started Austin FC’s most recent MLS match against the Portland Timbers.

Austin FC were professional if unspectacular in a 2-0 win over the visitors from a division below them. The win advances the Verde and Black to the round of 16 in the U.S. Open Cup. It was Austin FC’s first victory in all competitions since their 2-0 second-leg win against Violette back on March 14th – a win that was overshadowed by Austin FC losing the tie 3-2 on aggregate.

From a fan’s perspective, the highlight of the evening almost certainly had to be Rodney Redes scoring his first Austin FC goal in a competitive match. Redes gave the hosts an early 1-0 lead with a slick header from a Rigoni corner kick. Austin FC’s first-ever signing’s failure to find the back of the net in a fixture with stakes had become a source of equal-parts humor and frustration with the Verde faithful.

Injuries to Sebastian Driussi and Diego Fagundez have led to an increase in playing time for Redes of late and the Paraguayan has responded by turning in his best performances in an Austin FC shirt. To go along with his first goal against New Mexico, Redes picked up his first Austin FC assist in April 29th’s 2-2 draw with the San Jose Earthquakes.

“I’ve always worked hard, and I knew that there was going to come a point that I was going to start and I was going to be able to get those minutes,” Redes said after the match.

But the most intriguing aspect of the evening may have been the formation Austin FC lined up in. For the second-straight contest, Wolff elected to send his team out in a 3-4-3 shape that maximized width in attack and ensured solidity in defense. The biggest beneficiary of Austin FC’s switch to a back three has been the man playing left wingback: Adam Lundqvist. The ex-Houston Dynamo served up a nice assist to Maxi Urruti for Austin FC’s second goal.

“I think his last two performances have been quite strong both offensively and defensively,” Wolff said in his post-match press conference. “It gives him a little bit more freedom to be aggressive in a back five. I think his quality, his service, his running is what he really enjoys doing.”

Lundqvist agreed that the 3-4-3 gives him more freedom. “This formation the way it’s set up gives me a little bit more freedom to go forward,” he said after the match with the caveat that formations are just “numbers on a board.”

There’s a fluidity to Austin FC’s play at its best that does render formations as numbers on a board or as Pep Guardiola once said “telephone numbers.” Austin FC haven’t been at their best for much of 2023 though, and playing with an extra center-back has unleashed other members of the team.

Whether Austin FC stick with the 3-4-3 when everyone is fit (if everyone is ever fit) will be interesting to see. Tougher opponents than New Mexico United, starting with FC Dallas’ visit to Q2 Stadium on Saturday night, await Austin FC.

Eric McCoy

See Full Bio